Omitted field of study #1: Anomalous neuroscience cases
- Physician John Lorber's cases of many people who had above-average intelligence despite having lost most of their brains due to hydrocephalus.
- Many cases of people who experienced very little loss of mental ability or memory, even though half of their brains were removed in the operation known as hemispherectomy, to treat bad epileptic seizures.
- Karl's Lashley's cases, in which animals trained to perform some task could perform the task well after various fractions of their brains were removed.
- Cases of people (sometimes called savants) who displayed far-above-normal mental powers of some type or some extraordinary mental skill despite having some severe physical shortfall of the brain.
For example, let us consider the claims of typical evolutionary biologists. Such persons claim that all human abilities have an evolutionary explanation. Even without considering paranormal phenomena, this claim has seemed utterly implausible to many. The problem is that humans seem to have many mental characteristics and capabilities that cannot at all be explained as being the result of natural selection: things like philosophical reasoning ability, scientific reasoning, advanced mathematical reasoning, artistic creativity, spirituality, and altruism. Such things would not have increased a human's likelihood of surviving in the wild, and cannot be explained as the product of natural selection. This was admitted by the co-founder of the theory of natural selection, Alfred Russel Wallace, who wrote a long essay explaining carefully why natural selection cannot explain the more advanced human mental capabilities.
A general course in engineering should be mandatory for anyone getting a degree in evolutionary biology. Such a course could include a thorough study of software engineering. Students would learn about how engineering products are never produced by the process of accumulation that evolutionary biologists claim causes magnificent biological engineering effects. They would learn that great examples of engineering such as bridges and complex computer programs result not from some “piling up” process of accumulation, but from the extremely coordinated efforts of teams of intelligent workers and designers directed to achieve particular engineering ends. They would learn that while software engineers have played around with evolutionary algorithms for decades, such algorithms are not significantly used in the production of commercial software, because they are not effective in producing impressive engineering results.
Omitted field of study #6: computer information systems
- There is no computer that has any real understanding of anything, and computers have no actual mental experiences such as humans have.
- Computers are able to store information reliably because they have physical components such as hard drives and zip drives where information can exist in a stable unchanging state for years. In this sense, they are entirely different from what we find in human synapses, where the average lifetime of protein molecules is only a few weeks or less, meaning synapses have none of the stability that computer information storage components have.
- Computers are able to transmit information very reliably by using very low-noise electrical circuits completely different from the very high-noise neurons and synapses in the brain, which seem to be incapable of transmitting information very reliably.
- Computers are able to retrieve information very quickly because they use a variety of things (such as indexing and a storage positioning system) unlike anything that exists in the human brain. Your computer knows how to retrieve something from some very exact coordinate on a hard drive, but the brain has no coordinate system allowing retrieval from very exact positions.
- A computer is able to retrieve information quickly and write information quickly because it has exact hardware for doing both of those things (what is called a read-write head), and that component is unlike anything that exists in the brain, where no one has found either a mechanism for writing memories or a mechanism for reading them.
- A computer is able to store information because it makes use of sophisticated encoding protocols carefully worked out by designers, things such as the ASCII code, and the algorithm for converting ASCII to binary. No such encoding protocols have ever been discovered in the brain, with the exception of the genetic code that can only represent amino acids rather than learned memories.
- A computer is able to perform tasks such as information storage and retrieval because it has a whole very elaborate software infrastructure (such as an operating system) unlike anything known to exist in the human brain or in DNA.
- Steven Wiltshire has repeatedly shown the ability to accurately draw an entire skyline after seeing it only one time.
- Mathematician and computer scientist Herman Goldstine wrote this about the legendary mathematician John von Neumann: "One of his remarkable abilities was his power of absolute recall. As far as I could tell, von Neumann was able on once reading a book or article to quote it back verbatim; moreover, he could do it years later without hesitation."
- According to an article in the LA Times, Kim Peek could recall the contents of 12,000 books he had read, even though his brain was severely damaged, and he lacked most or all of the corpus callosum fibers that connect the two hemispheres of the brain.
- According to one book, "John Fuller, a land agent, of the county of Norfolk, could correctly write out a sermon or lecture after hearing it once; and one, Robert Dillon, could, in the morning, repeat six columns of a newspaper which he had read the preceding evening. More wonderful still was George Watson, who... could tell the date of every day since his childhood and how he had occupied himself on that day."
- The mathematician Leonhard Euler could recite the entire Aeneid from beginning to end, a work of 9896 lines.
- Mezzofanti could speak very well thirty different languages.
- A four-year-old girl demonstrated on TV her ability to speak seven different languages.
- Numerous Muslim scholars have memorized all 6000+ lines of their holy book, and some did this as early as age 10.
- According to a book, "The great thinker, Pascal, is said never to have forgotten anything he had ever known or read, and the same is told of Hugo, Grotius, Liebnitz, and Euler. All knew the whole of Virgil's 'Aeneid' by heart."
- The famous conductor Toscanini was able to keep conducting very successfully despite bad eyesight, because he had memorized the musical scores of a very large number of symphonies and operas.
- According to a book, a waiter in San Francisco could recall exactly what any customer had previously ordered, even if the customer had not visited the restaurant in years.
- The artist Franco Magnani (famed as "the Memory Artist") was able to draw "photographically accurate" drawings of his hometown that he had not seen in more than 30 years.
- G. C. Leland says: " It is recorded of a Slavonian Oriental Sect called the Bogomiles, which spread over Europe during the middle ages, that its members were required to memorize the Bible verbatim. Their latest historian, Dragomanoff, declares that there were none of them who did not memorize the New Testament at least; one of their bishops publicly proclaimed that, in his own diocese of four thousand communicants, there was not one unable to repeat the entire scriptures without an error."
- Akira Haraguchi was able to recite correctly from memory 100,000 digits of pi in 16 hours, in a filmed public exhibition.
- The fascinating 47-minute video here "The Boy Who Can't Forget" documents cases of Highly Superior Autobiographical Memory (HSAM), also called hyperthymesia. According to the article here a scientist named McGaugh "is adamant that the super memory demonstrated by the small number of people he and others have identified represents a genuine phenomenon." People with such a Highly Superior Autobiographical Memory (including Jill Price and Aureilien Hayman) can recall what happened to them every day in the past ten years.
- A book tells us this: "The geographer Maretus, narrates an instance of memory probably unequalled. He actually witnessed the feat, and had it attested by four Venetian nobles. He met in Padua, a young Corsican who had so powerful a memory that he could repeat as many as 36,000 words read over to him only once. Maretus, desiring to test this extraordinary youth, in the presence of his friends, read over to him an almost interminable list of words strung together anyhow in every language, and some mere gibberish. The audience was exhausted before the list, which had been written down for the sake of accuracy, and at the end of it the young Corsican smilingly began and repeated the entire list without a break and without a mistake. Then to show his remarkable power, he went over it backward, then every alternate word, first and fifth, and so on until his hearers were thoroughly exhausted, and had no hesitation in certifying that the memory of this individual was without a rival in the world, ancient or modern."
- Encyclopedia.com refers to the "miraculous photographic memory" of Thomas Babington Macaulay.
- Wikipedia.org states this about Daniel Tammet: "One of his most notable achievements was being able to recite Pi to 22,514 decimal places, taking him over five hours."
- According to an article on bbc.com, "Ask Nima Veiseh what he was doing for any day in the past 15 years, however, and he will give you the minutiae of the weather, what he was wearing, or even what side of the train he was sitting on his journey to work."
- Derek Paravicini was born 25 weeks early, with severe brain damage, but he has reliably demonstrated countless times the ability to very accurately play back on a keyboard any song that is played to him, note for note, even if he has never heard the song before.
- A nineteenth century work describes a similar ability in a prodigy known as Blind Tom: "The doctor then called for some one of the audience to come and play a piece of music for the first time in Tom's hearing, promising a very faithful imitation ; Miss Jones was persuaded to play a piece of her own composition, and hence unknown to Tom and the audience....When the lady was through and escorted from the stage, Tom sat down and played it through perfectly. " The next page states, "Tom executes some of the most difficult pieces of Beethoven, Mendelssohn, Bach, Gottschalk, Thalberg and others, and these he learnt by hearing them played."