It is a big mistake to assume that what you are reading in some science news story is typically something written by some source that is impartial and independent, some person who is an unbiased judge of truth. Most of the articles on science news sites are written by people working to further the interests of for-profit vested interests.
Below is a table showing some of the main sources of science news articles, and the owners of such sources.
News Source | Owner | Why the News Source Is Not Impartially Independent |
National Geographic magazine, web site and TV station | Owned 73% by the for-profit Walt Disney Company, and 27% by the non-profit National Geographic Society. | Mostly exists to create higher profits for the Walt Disney Company. |
Scientific American | Springer Nature, a for-profit publisher of scientific journals | Largely exists to promote the interests of a for-profit science paper publisher |
BBC Science Focus | Immediate Media Company/Our Media Ltd | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher |
Popular Mechanics | Hearst Corporation | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher |
Popular Science | Recurrent Ventures | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher |
PsyPost.org | PsyPost Media Inc. | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher |
Science Alert | Science Alert Ply Ltd | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher |
Quanta Magazine | Simons Foundation | NA (?) |
Medical XPress,Phys.org | Science X network, owned by Omicron Limited | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher, Omicron Limited |
Livescience.com | FuturePlc | Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher |
University Press Releases | Various universities | The press releases serve largely (1) to glorify professors and researchers working at the university, and to increase their citation counts; (2) to create the impression that the university sponsoring the research is a center of innovation (to help justify high tuition); (3) to maximize the chance of further federal funding. |
Science-related corporate press releases | Various for-profit corporations | The press releases serve largely (1) to glorify researchers working at the corporation; (2) to increase sales and service fees of the corporation; (3) to increase or stabilize the stock price of a particular corporation. |
Notice that in the table above we have Quanta Magazine listed as an exception. Unlike all the other sources, Quanta Magazine is owned by a non-profit organization, the Simons Foundation. The "About" page at the site says this:
"At Quanta Magazine, scientific accuracy is every bit as important as telling a good story. Since Quanta is a nonprofit foundation-funded publication, all of its resources go toward producing responsible, freely accessible journalism that is meticulously researched, reported, edited, copy-edited and fact-checked. And our editorial independence ensures the impartiality of our science coverage — our articles do not reflect or represent the views of the Simons Foundation."
That sounds impressive. So why is it that we so very often get in Quanta Magazine very bad error-ridden science journalism, and very big journalistic failures? For example, I detail in my post here the appalling failure of the magazine to properly alert the public about the COVID-19 epidemic (and well-advise about protective measures) during the first half of the year 2020, a year in which the epidemic starting killing huge numbers of Americans by about March.
On topics of science the magazine again and again is guilty of the most glaring failures. Quanta Magazine often has assigned its online articles about great unsolved problems in biology (involving mysteries a thousand miles over the heads of PhDs) to writers who lack even a bachelor's degree in biology or much of any history of writing on biology. Often it has assigned such articles to be written by people identified as "writing interns." The articles at Quanta Magazine often contain misleading prose, groundless boasts or the most glaring falsehoods. I discuss some examples of such poor journalism in my posts here and here and here and here.
The About page of Quanta Magazine has a headline of "Illuminating basic science and math research through public service journalism." The magazine is funded by the Simons Foundation, and we are told, "the Simons Foundation’s mission is to advance the frontiers of research in mathematics and the basic sciences." With all this talk about math and a long history of publication, you might expect that at least once Quanta Magazine would intelligently tackle the question of the mathematics of protein origination. But the magazine seems to have never done the math on this crucial issue.
The mathematics of protein origination is a central issue in the question of the origin of life. Recently Quanta Magazine published a "special series" on the origin of life. The articles in this "special series" were characterized by a complete failure to ever realistically discuss the mathematical problems involved in an origin of life from nonlife. The articles were characterized by an utter failure to realistically describe the complexity and organization of cells and their protein molecules and genes. Nowhere did the articles tell us that a self-reproducing cell is something requiring hundreds of separate types of protein inventions, each of which requires a special arrangement of hundreds of parts.
This failure to decently describe the complexity and organization of living things is the most gigantic failure of the literature of materialism. The probability of an unguided origination of a new type of biological innovation is inversely proportional to the complexity and organization of such an innovation. The more well-organized any biological innovation is, and the more well-arranged parts it requires, the less likely that it could be produced by accidental, unguided processes. So those who want you to believe in accidental originations of new types of biological innovations again and again fail to decently describe the complexity and organization of such innovations. The better that you understand such complexity and organization, the less likely you will be to believe in tales of accidental origins of such biological innovations.
Never once in the series of Quanta Magazine "special series" on the origin of life did we ever get a decent description of the complexity of protein molecules or a decent description of the complexity of cells. Instead we got articles such as this one containing the misleading visual below, which depicted protein molecules as enormously simpler than they are.
The article had some very misleading claims, such as the claim that "Miller had shown that life’s building blocks could form in the conditions of early Earth." No, Stanley Miller did not do any such thing, and a look at the photo of Miller's apparatus in the article shows that he constructed some very specially engineered glass apparatus unlike anything that would have existed on the early Earth. The article also made the inaccurate claim that "the creation of life's starting materials wasn't that difficult." No experiment realistically simulating the early Earth has ever produced the amino acids used by proteins.
Two other articles in the same recent Quanta Magazine "special series" were equally bad. One of them was an article ("How a Metabolic Spark Could Have Jump-Started Life") with the same old nonsense spouted again and again by people writing stupidly on the origin of life, the claim that life could have been "jump started" or "sparked" into existence. When people talk such way, they sound complexity-ignorant. You cannot "spark" your way into some state of vastly greater information-rich organization, just as you cannot "spark" your way into the construction of an automobile. Metabolism is something that only exists once life exists, so the idea of a "metabolic spark" originating life makes no sense.
Another article in the same recent Quanta Magazine "special series" was called "The Case for a Bubble at Life's Start." It was more of the old complexity-ignorant nonsense of talking about some fatty bubble, and trying to insinuate that could explain the origin of a cell. People who write such articles sound like people who fail to understand that even the simplest self-reproducing cell requires hundreds of different types of complex protein inventions, making such a cell exponentially more complex than a mere fatty bubble. At least the article has near its end a quote suggesting that the "case" mentioned in its title has the weight of a soap bubble. We read this:
" 'The idea of a lipid-only form of primitive life has never made sense to me,” said Jack Szostak, a Nobel Prize–winning biochemist at the University of Chicago. He cited the lack of experimental evidence that a lipid-based system can evolve. Plus, he said, how even simple lipids would have formed on the early Earth is 'the least well-developed aspect of all of prebiotic chemistry.' ”
Typically when materialists talk about evolution or the origin of life, they make claims that do not involve adequate thinking about the sky-high requirements for a natural appearance of new types of biological innovations. For example, materialists may speak most absurdly as if a benefit to survival or reproduction would be produced by every little mutation needed for some biological component. The truth (pretty much the exact opposite) is illustrated in the diagram below.
Now, for a protein such as an enzyme to function properly, it must have a sequence of amino acids close to its actual sequence. Experiments have shown that it is easy to ruin a protein molecule by making minor changes in its sequence of amino acids. Such changes will typically “break” the protein so that it will no longer fold in the right way to achieve the function that it performs. A biology textbook tells us, "Proteins are so precisely built that the change of even a few atoms in one amino acid can sometimes disrupt the structure of the whole molecule so severely that all function is lost." And we read on a science site, "Folded proteins are actually fragile structures, which can easily denature, or unfold." Another science site tells us, "Proteins are fragile molecules that are remarkably sensitive to changes in structure." But we can imagine that a protein molecule might still be functional if some minor changes were made in its sequence of amino acids.
So even under the probably-too-generous assumption that perhaps only half of a protein's amino acid sequence has to be just as it is, we still are left with a calculation suggesting that a functional protein could never form by chance. The probability above is about the probability of you correctly guessing the 10-digit phone numbers of 24 consecutive strangers. It would seem that some miracle of luck would be required for a particular type of functional protein molecule to form by chance.
You don't make these prohibitive odds any better by switching your analysis from proteins to genes, because you get the same type of prohibitive odds when dealing with genes. A gene is a string of symbols that must be just right for the gene to specify the amino acid sequence of a protein. The odds of getting a functional gene by random processes are like the odds of typing monkeys producing a functional grammatical paragraph of 400 characters or more.
The more deeply you consider the complexity of living things, the more prohibitive seem the chances of the accidental origin of life.
Doing the math correctly leads to the very general principle that accidents cannot produce very complex and useful instruction information. This principle matches our intuitions. If someone ever claimed that he spilled a big box of 500 Scrabble letters, and that they fell on the floor and accidentally produced a 100-word complex instruction that was very useful, you would never believe such a tale.
The type of math described above may be called combinatorial math or probability math. It is a type of math relatively easy to explain, and its principles are rather simple. But Quanta Magazine writers never seem to do the math describing the almost infinitely steep odds against complex biological innovations occurring by chance. Instead we have in the magazine many discussions of the obscure mathematics of things of very much smaller importance, or things of no clear importance because they are purely speculative.

















