Header 1

Our future, our universe, and other weighty topics


Saturday, November 21, 2026

Math-Oriented Quanta Magazine Never Does the Math on the Origin of Life

It is a big mistake to assume that what you are reading in some science news story is typically something written by some source that is impartial and independent, some person who is an unbiased judge of truth. Most of the articles on science news sites are written by people working to further the interests of for-profit vested interests. 

science news clickbait

Below is a table showing some of the main sources of science news articles, and the owners of such sources. 

News Source

Owner

Why the News Source Is Not Impartially Independent

National Geographic magazine, web site and TV station

Owned 73% by the for-profit Walt Disney Company,  and 27% by the non-profit National Geographic Society.

Mostly exists to create higher profits for the Walt Disney Company.

Scientific American

Springer Nature, a for-profit publisher of scientific journals

Largely exists to promote the interests of a for-profit science paper publisher

BBC Science Focus

Immediate Media Company/Our Media Ltd

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher

Popular Mechanics

Hearst Corporation

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher

Popular Science

Recurrent Ventures

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher

PsyPost.org

PsyPost Media Inc.

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher

Science Alert

Science Alert Ply Ltd

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher

Quanta Magazine

Simons Foundation

NA (?)

Medical XPress,Phys.org

Science X network, owned by Omicron Limited

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher, Omicron Limited

Livescience.com

FuturePlc

Mainly exists to create revenue for a for-profit publisher

University Press Releases

Various universities

The press releases serve largely (1) to glorify professors and researchers working at the university, and to increase their citation counts; (2) to create the impression that the university sponsoring the research is a center of innovation (to help justify high tuition); (3) to maximize the chance of further federal funding.

Science-related corporate press releases

Various for-profit corporations

The press releases serve largely (1) to glorify researchers working at the corporation; (2) to increase sales and service fees of the corporation; (3) to increase or stabilize the stock price of a particular corporation.


Notice that in the table above we have Quanta Magazine listed as an exception. Unlike all the other sources, Quanta Magazine is owned by a non-profit organization, the Simons Foundation. The "About" page at the site says this:

"At Quanta Magazine, scientific accuracy is every bit as important as telling a good story. Since Quanta is a nonprofit foundation-funded publication, all of its resources go toward producing responsible, freely accessible journalism that is meticulously researched, reported, edited, copy-edited and fact-checked. And our editorial independence ensures the impartiality of our science coverage — our articles do not reflect or represent the views of the Simons Foundation."

That sounds impressive. So why is it that we so very often get in Quanta Magazine very bad error-ridden science journalism, and very big journalistic failures? For example, I detail in my post here the appalling failure of the magazine to properly alert the public about the COVID-19 epidemic (and well-advise about protective measures) during the first half of the year 2020, a year in which the epidemic starting killing huge numbers of Americans by about March. 

On topics of science the magazine again and again is guilty of the most glaring failures. Quanta Magazine often has assigned its online articles about great unsolved problems in biology (involving mysteries a thousand miles over the heads of PhDs) to writers who lack even a bachelor's degree in biology or much of any history of writing on biology. Often it has assigned such articles to be written by people identified as "writing interns."  The articles at Quanta Magazine often contain misleading prose, groundless boasts or the most glaring falsehoods. I discuss some examples of such poor journalism in my posts here and here and here and here.

The About page of Quanta Magazine has a headline of "Illuminating basic science and math research through public service journalism."  The magazine is funded by the Simons Foundation, and we are told, "the Simons Foundation’s mission is to advance the frontiers of research in mathematics and the basic sciences."  With all this talk about math and a long history of publication, you might expect that at least once Quanta Magazine would intelligently tackle the question of the mathematics of protein origination. But the magazine seems to have never done the math on this crucial issue. 

The mathematics of protein origination is a central issue in the question of the origin of life. Recently Quanta Magazine published a "special series" on the origin of life. The articles in this "special series" were characterized by a complete failure to ever realistically discuss the mathematical problems involved in an origin of life from nonlife.  The articles were characterized by an utter failure to realistically describe the complexity and organization of cells and their protein molecules and genes. Nowhere did the articles tell us that a self-reproducing cell is something requiring hundreds of separate types of protein inventions, each of which requires a special arrangement of hundreds of parts. 

This failure to decently describe the complexity and organization of living things is the most gigantic failure of the literature of materialism. The probability of an unguided origination of a new type of biological innovation is inversely proportional to the complexity and organization of such an innovation. The more well-organized any biological innovation is, and the more well-arranged parts it requires, the less likely that it could be produced by accidental, unguided processes.  So those who want you to believe in accidental originations of new types of biological innovations again and again fail to decently describe the complexity and organization of such innovations. The better that you understand such complexity and organization, the less likely you will be to believe in tales of accidental origins of such biological innovations. 

Never once in the series of Quanta Magazine "special series" on the origin of life did we ever get a decent description of the complexity of protein molecules or a decent description of the complexity of cells. Instead we got articles such as this one containing the misleading visual below, which depicted protein molecules as enormously simpler than they are.

misleading diagram of a protein molecule

The article had some very misleading claims, such as the claim that "Miller had shown that life’s building blocks could form in the conditions of early Earth." No, Stanley Miller did not do any such thing, and a look at the photo of Miller's apparatus in the article shows that he constructed some very specially engineered glass apparatus unlike anything that would have existed on the early Earth.  The article also made the inaccurate claim that "the creation of life's starting materials wasn't that difficult." No experiment realistically simulating the early Earth has ever produced the amino acids used by proteins. 

Two other articles in the same recent Quanta Magazine "special series" were equally bad. One of them was an article ("How a Metabolic Spark Could Have Jump-Started Life") with the same old nonsense spouted again and again by people writing stupidly on the origin of life, the claim that life could have been "jump started" or "sparked" into existence. When people talk such way, they sound complexity-ignorant. You cannot "spark" your way into some state of vastly greater information-rich organization, just as you cannot "spark" your way into the construction of an automobile.  Metabolism is something that only exists once life exists, so the idea of a "metabolic spark" originating life makes no sense. 

Another article in the same recent Quanta Magazine "special series" was called "The Case for a Bubble at Life's Start." It was more of the old complexity-ignorant nonsense of talking about some fatty bubble, and trying to insinuate that could explain the origin of a cell.  People who write such articles sound like people who fail to understand that even the simplest self-reproducing cell requires hundreds of different types of complex protein inventions, making such a cell exponentially more complex than a mere fatty bubble.  At least the article has near its end a quote suggesting that the "case" mentioned in its title has the weight of a soap bubble. We read this:

" 'The idea of a lipid-only form of primitive life has never made sense to me,” said Jack Szostak, a Nobel Prize–winning biochemist at the University of Chicago. He cited the lack of experimental evidence that a lipid-based system can evolve. Plus, he said, how even simple lipids would have formed on the early Earth is 'the least well-developed aspect of all of prebiotic chemistry.' ”

Typically when materialists talk about evolution or the origin of life, they make claims that do not involve adequate thinking about the sky-high requirements for a natural appearance of new types of biological innovations. For example, materialists may speak most absurdly as if a benefit to survival or reproduction would be produced by every little mutation needed for some biological component. The truth (pretty much the exact opposite) is illustrated in the diagram below. 

requirements threhsolds

Lets look at some of the relevant math. In a human body there are more than 20,000 different types of proteins, each a separate type of complex invention. There are 20 amino acids used by living things. The median amino acid length of a human protein is about 375 amino acids. So to calculate the chance of a set of amino acids randomly forming into the exact set of amino acids used by a functional protein such as an enzyme, the correct figure is 1 in 20 to the three-hundred-and-seventy-fifth power. This is a probability of about 1 in 10 to the four-hundred-eighty-seventh power. Very precisely, we can say that the chance of a random sequence of amino acids exactly matching that of a protein with 375 amino acids is a probability of about 1 in 7.695704335 X 10487. That is a probability similar to the probability of you correctly guessing (with 100% accuracy) the ten-digit telephone numbers of 48 consecutive strangers. The calculation is shown in the visual below:

Now, for a protein such as an enzyme to function properly, it must have a sequence of amino acids close to its actual sequence. Experiments have shown that it is easy to ruin a protein molecule by making minor changes in its sequence of amino acids. Such changes will typically “break” the protein so that it will no longer fold in the right way to achieve the function that it performs. A biology textbook tells us, "Proteins are so precisely built that the change of even a few atoms in one amino acid can sometimes disrupt the structure of the whole molecule so severely that all function is lost." And we read on a science site, "Folded proteins are actually fragile structures, which can easily denature, or unfold." Another science site tells us, "Proteins are fragile molecules that are remarkably sensitive to changes in structure." But we can imagine that a protein molecule might still be functional if some minor changes were made in its sequence of amino acids.

Let us assume that for a protein molecule to retain its function, at least half of the amino acids in a functional protein have to exist in the exact sequence found in the protein. Under such an assumption, to calculate the chance of the functional protein forming by chance, rather than calculating a probability of 1 in 20 to the three-hundredth-and-seventh-fifth power, we might calculate a probability of 1 in 20 to the one-hundred-eighty-seventh power (187 being about half of 375). This would give us a probability equal to about 1 in 10 to the two hundred and forty-third power, a probability of about 1 in 10243. The calculation shown below gives us the number you must divide by 1. 


So even under the probably-too-generous assumption that perhaps only half of a protein's amino acid sequence has to be just as it is, we still are left with a calculation suggesting that a functional protein could never form by chance. The probability above is about the probability of you correctly guessing the 10-digit phone numbers of 24 consecutive strangers. It would seem that some miracle of luck would be required for a particular type of functional protein molecule to form by chance. 

If you are calculating the probability of accidentally getting all of hundreds of types of proteins needed for the origin of life, then you are talking about a likelihood very, very many orders of magnitude smaller than the probability of you getting a single type of functional protein molecule by chance. Similarly if a large hall full of people have boxes of Scrabble letters, the chance of one of them shaking their box, throwing the letters to the ground, and spelling out a functional paragraph is one very tiny probability; but the chance of 200 people in the same hall ever doing that on the same evening is some other very tiny probability much, much smaller than .0000000000000000000000000000000001 of the first probability (very, very many times smaller than a millionth of a billionth of a trillionth of a quadrillionth of a quintillionth of a sextillionth of the first probability). 

Below is  quote from a scientific paper you can read here.

"In 2016, the construction of a bacterial cell that encoded only the genes necessary for cell life and rapid cell growth in rich laboratory media was announced. The creation of this 'minimal cell' was widely heralded as a scientific milestone. The organism was called JCVI-Syn3.0. It has a smaller genome (531,490 bp) than that of any known organism that can be grown in axenic culture. There are only 438 protein-coding genes and 35 RNA-coding genes (). Although there have been more than 2000 scientific papers published that mentioned minimal bacterial cells, and creating one has been an ambition of the scientific community since the 1930s, the bacterium JCVI-Syn3.0 is the first real minimal cell."

You don't make these prohibitive odds any better by switching your analysis from proteins to genes, because you get the same type of prohibitive odds when dealing with genes.  A gene is a string of symbols that must be just right for the gene to specify the amino acid sequence of a protein.  The odds of getting a functional gene by random processes are like the odds of typing monkeys producing a functional grammatical paragraph of 400 characters or more. 

The more deeply you consider the complexity of living things, the more prohibitive seem the chances  of the accidental origin of life.  

Doing the math correctly leads to the very general principle that accidents cannot produce very complex and useful instruction information. This principle matches our intuitions. If someone ever claimed that he spilled a big box of 500 Scrabble letters, and that they fell on the floor and accidentally produced a 100-word complex instruction that was very useful, you would never believe such a tale. 

accidents cannot invent complex things

The type of math described above may be called combinatorial math or probability math. It is a type of math relatively easy to explain, and its principles are rather simple. But Quanta Magazine writers never seem to do the math describing the almost infinitely steep odds against complex biological innovations occurring by chance.  Instead we have in the magazine many discussions of the obscure mathematics of things of very much smaller importance, or things of no clear importance because they are purely speculative.

Below is a relevant quote:

"The most puzzling aspect of this convolution is that all the parts and processes of extant life depend on all the other parts and processes in a circular way. For example, a complex metabolism is needed to make the biochemicals that are required for the assembly of those protein enzymes that are needed to catalyze the reactions of ... metabolism itself ! Similarly, the nucleic acid molecules, DNA and RNA, are needed to encode the information that specifies the assembly of proteins—the workhorse molecules of life-- which are required to make — yes, you guessed it, DNA and RNA. To make matters even more perplexing, to allow all of these molecules to accomplish their tasks, they need cell membranes that keep all the molecular players boxed together. But cell membranes are made of fatty compounds known as lipids, and those are synthesized by protein enzymes. This type of self-referential or recursive activity (reminiscent of a famous drawing by graphic artist M. C. Esther in which two hands are drawing each other) is so deeply embedded in the fabric of modern living organisms, that for many years it seemed that some miraculous event would have been required to bridge the gap between a random mixture of chemicals and the highly organized structure of a living cell. Even as late as 1981, Francis Crick, the co-discoverer of the double-helix structure of DNA, emphasized that 'an honest man, armed with all the knowledge available to us now, could only state that in some sense, the origin of life appears at the moment to be almost a miracle, so many are the conditions which would have had to have been satisfied to get it going.' "  -- Astrophysicist Mario Livio and Nobel Prize winning chemistry professor Jack Szostak, "Is Earth Exceptional? The Quest for Cosmic Life," pages 10-11. 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Nagel Just Got a Million-Dollar Prize, But News Accounts Don't Mention His Darwinism Critique

Big money achievement prizes such as the Nobel Prize have long been a kind of "old boy's club" affair, in which prizes seemed to almost never go to very innovative contrarian thinkers, but instead seemed to go only to members of an Old Guard teaching the orthodoxy of prevailing belief customs in academia. But now there has been a million-dollar prize awarded to Thomas Nagel, who is quite a contrarian thinker. Nagel is the author of the book Mind and Cosmos: Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature Is Almost Certainly False. 

Prize to Darwinism critic

You can read the beginning of that book using the link here. Below is a quotation from page 5, in which Nagel states this:

"The argument from the failure of psychophysical reductionism is a philosophical one, but I believe there are independent empirical reasons to be skeptical about the truth of reductionism in biology. Physico-chemical reductionism in biology is the orthodox view, and any resistance to it is regarded as not only scientifically but politically incorrect. But for a long time I have found the materialist account of how we and our fellow organisms came to exist hard to believe, including the standard version of how the evolutionary process works. The more we learn about the chemical basis of life and the intricacy of the genetic code, the more unbelievable the standard account becomes.....It seems to me that, as it is usually presented, the current orthodoxy about the cosmic order is the product of governing assumptions that are unsupported, and that it flies in the face of common sense."

On the next page Nagel states this:

"I would like to defend the untutored reaction of incredulity to the reductionist neo-Darwinian account of the origin and evolution of life. It is prima facie implausible that life as we know is the result of physical accidents together with the mechanism of natural selection...What is lacking, to my knowledge, is a credible argument that has a nonnegligible probability of being true."

On page 7 Nagel states this about his skepticism of materialist explanations: 

"My skepticism is not based on religious belief, or on a belief in any definite alternative. It just a belief that the available scientific evidence, in spite of the consensus of scientific opinion, does not in this matter rationally require us to subordinate the incredulity of common sense. That is especially true with regard to the origin of life."

On pages 8 to 9 Nagel says this:

"It is no longer legitimate simply to imagine a sequence of gradually evolving phenotypes, as if their appearance through mutations in the DNA were unproblematic -- as Richard Dawkins does for the evolution of the eye. With regard to the origin of life, the problem is much harder, since the option of evolution by natural selection is no longer available. And the coming into existence of the genetic code -- an arbitrary mapping of nucleotide sequences into amino acids, together with mechanisms that can read the code and carry out its instructions -- seems particularly resistant to being revealed as probable given physical law alone."

Among the many reasons for the illegitimacy which Nagel refers to is that DNA does not specify anatomy (contrary to false claims often made), and does not even specify how to make any type of cell or any of the organelles from which cells are made. So there are no conceivable DNA mutations that could explain how there arose the enormously complex anatomy and specialized cells needed for vision. 

Although on page 8 of his Mind and Cosmos book Nagel speaks of the arguments of intelligent design theorists Michael Behe and Stephen Meyer as being "of great interest in themselves," Nagel in the book claims to be an atheist. But his is a strange type of atheism indeed -- one that postulates that there must be some mysterious poorly understood reality in nature that is causing it to produce minds and biological effects in a way that we do not understand. You might say that he is postulating some gigantic undiscovered X Factor that is acting rather like some deity trying to produce wonders of biology and wonders of mind.  Some might suspect that his position is a kind of "halfway house" between atheism and theism.  

How has the mainstream press reacted to this announcement? They have reacted in a way that can be described as "cover-up the critique." For example, Forbes has an article on the awarding of the prize to Nagel. But the article makes no mention of his criticism of Darwinism or materialism. The article mentions Nagel's main work, giving us only a short version of the title (Mind and Cosmos) without giving us the full version of the title, which is Mind and Cosmos: Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature Is Almost Certainly False. 

Similarly, New York University has a press release on the awarding of the million-dollar prize to Nagel, a press release that also fails to mention  his criticism of Darwinism and materialism.  The press release also fails to mention Nagel's main book Mind and Cosmos.

The institution awarding the million-dollar prize (the Berggruen Institute) did a little better, as it issued a press release announcing the award, and that press release stated this:

"In Mind and Cosmos (2012), he offers a provocative challenge to the prevailing Darwinian evolutionary accounts of human mind and cognition. He argues against an understanding of human consciousness as a product of merely physical evolution, positing instead that the mind is a basic element of reality."

But this was still rather a cover-up, as the press release makes it sound like Nagel criticized only the Darwinian account of the origin of minds.  The passages I quoted above (and the subtitle of the Mind and Cosmos book) make it perfectly clear that Nagel was sharply critical of not just the Darwinian account of the mind, but also the Darwinian account of the origin of complex biology and the materialist account of the origin of life. 

Below is what I get when I ask Google Gemini to produce an infographic summarizing Nagel's Mind and Cosmos book:

Thomas Nagel's Mind and Cosmos

Looking at the infographic summary above, I agree with most of it; but I sharply disagree with the language in which mind is described as a "feature" or an "aspect." Human minds are as complex a reality as human bodies. Human minds and human mental experiences are an enormously complex multifaceted reality consisting mainly of a great wealth of capabilities; and such a reality is no mere "feature" or "aspect." An erroneous description of the human mind as a mere "aspect" or "feature" or "property" is a pillar of arguments for panpsychism, an erring philosophy of mind that is very much centered upon "shadow-speaking" descriptions of human minds, in which human minds are described as if they are mere shadows of what human minds are. 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

A Doctor's 1937 Account of an Out-of-Body Experience

Sir Auckland Geddes was a doctor and professor of anatomy who eventually served for years as the British ambassador to the United States. He had an extremely distinguished career serving in a variety of lofty roles.  In 1937  Geddes addressed a dissertation to the Edinburgh Medical Journal, one you can read here.  His address (entitled "A Voice From the Grandstand") included some startling accounts. One was an account of long-distance telepathy, stretching from India to Scotland. Geddes stated this on page 367:

"A sister in Edinburgh has a severe heart attack as a result of shock and anxiety, because she knows intuitively that her brother, stationed in India, has met with some disaster, though no physical message of any sort has passed. Will you tell me what scientific steps you will take in Edinburgh to deal with the true cause and not the symptoms of the illness ? This is an actual case. The knowledge, of course, was conveyed by Telepathy, but what does that mean ? It is a mere word, and adds nothing to what I have just said she felt at a distance. Yet telepathy, as a result of the research carried out in Professor Rhine's Department of Psychology, Duke University, must I think be accepted as a primary datum of science." 

Geddes was telling the medical authorities he was addressing: telepathy is a fact of science. No one who has seriously studied the evidence gathered by Professor Joseph Rhine should be at all surprised by this statement.  The evidence Rhine gathered was indeed "smoking gun" evidence showing the existence of ESP and telepathy, as I discuss in my post "When Rhine and Pearce Got Smoking Gun Evidence for ESP," which you can read here. Very many scientific authorities conceded in that decade that telepathy had been well-proven. But senselessly in later decades professors developed a kind of amnesia about previous research on this topic, and seriously studying the topic became a senseless taboo of science professors. 

Auckland Geddes (Wikipedia Commons)

Geddes then tells us (on page 368) of another astonishing case, one of endless medical cases in which the mind seems to have a mysterious influence on the body, in a way suggestive of mind-over-matter. We read of a mysterious cure of eczema, a disease involving red, itchy patches on the skin.

"Another case : A girl, a victim for years of extremely bad eczema, receives a letter which fills her with joy and thankfulness and within a few days the skin of her face and arms becomes soft and normal and, what is more, she suddenly acquires beauty and dignity. In this particular case the skin condition existed years before the tension that was ended by the letter. In the interval she had suffered much at the hands of many physicians, but they had all failed 'to cure the eczema.' "

On page 373 Geddes begins to tell a narrative that was probably unlike any that his doctor audience had heard.  In all likelihood the event described was probably something that occurred to Geddes himself.  Geddes states that he will read a "unique document," but it is not the first account of an out-of-body experience. But since such experiences were little known prior to 1937, we can excuse Geddes' presumption that the experience was unique. He first states this:

"I am in a position to read to you to-night an unique document. It is the record of the experience of a man who passed into the very portals of death and was brought back to life by medical treatment. The record was taken down in shorthand by a skilled secretary as life was re-establishing itself. Its existence has been known to some of your teachers, perhaps to some of you, for some time. I have to request that those who know to whom this strange experience befell will respect the anonymity and professional secrecy in which this communication is veiled."

He then gives us the first-hand narrative of an out-of-body experience:

"On Saturday, November 9th, a few minutes after midnight, I began to feel very ill, and by 2 o'clock was definitely suffering from acute gastro-enteritis, which kept me vomiting and purging until about 8 o'clock. . . . By 10 o'clock I had developed all the symptoms of very acute poisoning ; intense gastro-intestinal pain, diarrhea ; pulse and respirations becoming quite impossible to count. I wanted to ring for assistance, but found I could not, and so quite placidly gave up the attempt. I realised I was very ill and very quickly reviewed my whole financial position : thereafter at no time did my consciousness appear to me to be in any way dimmed, but I suddenly realised that my consciousness was separating from another consciousness, which was also me. These for purposes of description we could call the A and B consciousness, and throughout what follows the ego attached itself to the A consciousness. The B personality I recognised as belonging to the body, and as my physical condition grew worse and the heart was fibrillating rather than beating, I realised that the B consciousness belonging to the body was beginning to show signs of being composite, that is, built up of ' consciousnesses ' from the head, the heart, the viscera, etc. These components became more individual and the B consciousness began to disintegrate, while the A consciousness which was now me, seemed to be altogether outside my body, which it could see. Gradually I realised that I could see not only my body and the bed in which it was, but everything in the whole house and garden, and then I realised that I was seeing not only ' things ' at home, but in London and in Scotland, in fact wherever my attention was directed it seemed to me ; and the explanation which I received, from what source I do not know, but which I found myself calling  to myself my mentor, was that I was free in a time dimension of space, wherein ' now ' was in some way equivalent to 1 here ' in the ordinary three-dimensional space of everyday life. 

I next realised that my vision included not only 'things' in the ordinary three-dimensional world, but also 'things' in these four or more dimensional places that I was in. From now on the description is and must be entirely metaphorical, because there are no words which really describe what I saw or rather appreciated. Although I had no body I had what appeared to be perfect two-eyed vision, and what I saw can only be described in this way, that I was conscious of a psychic stream flowing with life through time, and this gave me the impression of being visible, and it seemed to me to have a particularly intense iridescence. I understood from my mentor that all our brains are just end organs projecting as it were from the three-dimensional universe into the psychic stream and flowing with it into the fourth and fifth dimensions. Around each brain, as I saw it, there seemed to be what I can only describe in ordinary words as a condensation of the psychic stream, which formed in each case as though it were a cloud ; only it was not a cloud. 

While I was just appreciating this, the mentor who was conveying information to me explained that the fourth dimension was in everything existing in the three-dimensional space, and at the same time everything in the three-dimensional space existed in the fourth dimension and also in the fifth dimension, and I at the time quite clearly understood what was meant, and quite understood how ' now ' in the fourth-dimensional universe was just the same to all intents and purposes as 'here' in a three-dimensional universe, that is to say a four-dimensional being was everywhere in the ' now,' just as one is ' everywhere ' in the ' here ' in a three-dimensional view of things. I then realised that I myself was a condensation, as it were, in the psychic stream, a sort of cloud that was not a cloud, and the visual impression I had of myself was blue. Gradually I began to recognise people, and I saw the psychic condensation attached to A, B, C, D, E, F and to quite a number of men that I know, especially to G and H. In addition, I saw quite a number of people that I know had very little psychic condensation at all attached to them. In addition to those just mentioned, I saw ' I ' very clearly and she also gave a visual impression of blueness ; ' A ' gave purple and dark red ; ' B pink ; ' D rather indefinite grey brown ; ' E ' pearly ; and ' F ' apricot colour ; ' G ' was definitely brown. Each of these condensations varied from all the others in bulk, sharpness of outline and apparent solidity. 

Just as I began to grasp all these I saw ' A ' enter my bedroom ; I realised she got a terrible shock, and I saw her hurry to the telephone ; I saw my doctor leave his patients and come very quickly, and heard him say or saw him think ' He is nearly gone.' I heard him quite clearly speaking to me on the bed, but I was not in touch with the body and could not answer him. I was really cross when he took a syringe and rapidly injected my body with something, which I afterwards learned was camphor. As the heart began to beat more strongly, I was drawn back, and I was intensely annoyed, because I was so interested and just beginning to understand where I was and what I was ' seeing.' I came back into the body really angry at being pulled back, and once I was back all the clarity of vision of anything and everything disappeared and I was just possessed of a glimmer of consciousness, which was suffused with pain.  

 It is surprising to note that this dream, vision or experience has shown no tendency to fade like a dream would fade, nor has it shown any tendency that I am aware of to grow or to rationalise itself as a dream would do. I think that the whole thing simply means that but for medical treatment of a peculiarly prompt and vigorous kind, I was dead to the three-dimensional universe. If this is so and if in fact the experience of liberation of consciousness in the fourth-dimensional universe is not imagination, it is a most important matter to place on record. Since my return with the injections there had been no repetition of any sort or kind of the experience or of the clear understanding that I seemed to have while I was free from the body."

The account above of someone describing himself as something like a blue cloud or condensation may have corroboration in the account below.  Below is a very interesting account of a doctor who claimed to have twice seen a soul departing from the body when someone was dying. The doctor claimed that the souls looked like blue smoke. 

soul departing body

You can read the account here:

https://books.google.com/books?id=jvFCAAAAIBAJ&pg=PA2&dq=deathbed+vision&article_id=2891,7442987#v=onepage&q=deathbed%20vision&f=false

The account here tells the same account in fewer words:

soul leaving body

An old newspaper account discusses something similar seen by others at a deathbed: one involving a blue flame, and the other a dark vapor leaving the head, forming into a human figure:

deathbed vision

Anyone interested in this topic of strange lights or strange mists seen at a deathbed should read my post here, which discusses several other cases of this type. 

I've noticed a tendency in recent press articles about out-of-body experiences or near-death experiences. We may have a description of one or more such experiences, and then at the end of the article there may be a claim to the effect that scientists have a model to explain such things, with the claim having a link to a paper co-authored by Charlotte Martial. For a long discussion of that paper and its many unbelievable speculations and inaccuracies, see my post here, entitled "Physically Unrealistic NEPTUNE 'Model' of Near-Death Experiences Is a Misleading Mishmash."  Engaging in groundless speculation, Martial's paper attempts to insinuate that increases in common neurotransmitters may cause hallucinations, ignoring the reality that experimenters have sometimes caused super-massive increases in such neurotransmitters (by injection or infusion), without any hallucinations being reported. 

If the topic of this post interested you, check out my free book "Psychics and Paranormal Phenomena," available on www.archive.org using the link here. Using the native www.archive.org file viewer in single-page mode by pressing the [] symbol at the bottom,  you can conveniently read the whole book by finger swiping. Scholars who are interested in following the links may prefer to download the book as a PDF file, which will allow opening links by right-clicking on a link. 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Many Ways Scientists Can "Sweep Under the Rug" Observations They Don't Want

Scientists sometimes portray themselves as people who do not hesitate to follow the evidence wherever it points. But in reality many a modern expert shows a strong tendency to evade and stifle evidence that conflicts with his cherished dogmas, his entrenched ideas about the way reality works. There are quite a few ways in which an expert may evade or stifle some observational result that he doesn't want to accept. Let's look at some of these ways that scientists and other experts "sweep under the rug" observations they wish to ignore. 

Way #1: Just “File-Drawer” the Unwanted Result

The term “file drawer effect" refers to the existence of unpublished scientific studies. After running a study getting an undesired result, a scientist may decide to not even write up the study as a scientific paper. It is believed that the file drawers of scientists contain data on many studies that were never written up as papers, and never published in scientific journals.

If a scientist gets a negative result failing to show an effect he was looking for, the scientist may never write up the experiment as a paper, and he may justify this by saying that it would be hard to get the paper published, because scientific journals don't like to publish negative results. Or, if the results seem to conflict with existing dogmas, the scientist may think to himself that it would be hard to get a paper with such a result published, given existing prejudices. A study making surveys of scientists found that 63% of US psychologists surveyed and 63% of evolution researchers surveyed confessed to "not reporting studies or variables that failed to reach statistical significance (e.g. p ≤0.05) or some other desired statistical threshold." This is quite the intellectual sin, because it is just as important to report negative results as it is to report positive results. 

Way #2: Prune the Data to Remove the Unwanted Result

When a scientist gets an unwanted result in an experiment or a meta-analysis of previously published papers, the scientist might try to get a better result by removing some of the data items collected, or removing some of the scientific papers included in the meta-analysis. If the scientist collected the data himself, he may arbitrarily remove any extreme data item, on the grounds that it was an “outlier.” Or he may apply some filter criteria that gets rid of certain data items. For example, if a study with 1000 subjects is analyzing the safety of a drug, and 100 of them died not long after taking the drug, some of those hundred troubling data points might be removed by introducing some inclusion criteria which excludes most of those who died.

Or if a scientist is doing a meta-analysis of 100 studies of the effectiveness of some medical technique not popular with scientists (for example, acupuncture or homeopathy), and the result ends up showing an effectiveness for the technique, this undesired result can be modified by modifying the inclusion criteria used to decide which studies will be included in the meta-analysis. Similarly, data items may be yanked out of a scientific paper, to help the paper achieve something that may be reported as "statistically significant." A study making surveys of scientists found that 38% of US psychologists surveyed and 23.9% of evolution researchers surveyed confessed to "deciding to exclude data points after first checking the impact on statistical significance."

p-hacking

Way #3: Keep on Collecting More Data Until You Get a Result Less Unwanted

If a scientist collects a certain amount of observational data, and he is left with an unwanted result, another technique he can use to get a more desirable result is to continue collecting more data until a more desirable result is achieved. For example, lets us imagine a scientist tries to do a study showing that lots of television watching increases your chance of sudden cardiac death. Suppose the scientist gets data on 10,000 years of living of 1000 subjects, but does not find the effect he is looking for. The scientists can just keep collecting more data, such as trying to get data on 20,000 years of living of 2000 subjects. As soon as the desired result appears, the scientist can then stop collecting data, and write up his paper for publication. It is easy to see how such a technique can distort reality. A study making surveys of scientists found that 55.9% of US psychologists surveyed and 50.7% of evolution researchers surveyed confessed to "collecting more data after inspecting whether the results are statistically significant."  

Way #4: Just Switch the Hypothesis If the Original Hypothesis Is Not Supported by the Experiment

A very common technique is what is called HARKing, which stands for Hypothesizing After Results are Known. A scientific experiment is supposed to state a hypothesis, gather data, and then analyze whether the data supports the hypothesis. But imagine you are some scientist gathering data that does not support the original hypothesis. Rather than writing this up as a result against the original hypothesis, you can come up with some other hypothesis after the data has been collected, and then write up the scientific experiment describing it as a study that confirms the new hypothesis. You might avoid even mentioning that the experiment had failed to confirm the original hypothesis. One problem with this is that it has the effect of stifling or covering up a negative result which should have been the main news item coming from the scientific paper. The bad effects of Hypothesizing After Results Are Known are described here.

There is a general technique that can be used to prevent or discourage the four effects just describe. The technique is for institutions to arrange for pre-registered studies with guaranteed publication. Under such a method, a scientist has to publish in writing (before collecting data) the hypothesis that he is testing, and specify in detail the exact experimental method that will be used, including data inclusion criteria. Then regardless of the result achieved, the result must be written up and published in a journal, in a way true to the original experimental design specification. It is widely recognized that such pre-registration and guaranteed publication would result in more reliable and robust scientific papers, with a reduction in misleading publication bias and file-drawer effects. But the scientific community has made almost no effort to use such a methodology. 

A study making surveys of scientists found that 27% of US psychologists surveyed and 54% of evolution researchers surveyed confessed to "reporting an unexpected finding as having been predicted from the start."  Should this cause us to suspect that evolution researchers are more prone to lie than psychology researchers? 

Way #5: Mask the Undesired Result with a Paper Title Not Mentioning It

Scientists write the titles of their own papers, and such titles can often mask or hide undesired results. An example was a scientific paper describing an attempt to look for long-lived proteins in the synapses of the brain, proteins that might help to explain human memories that can last for 50 years. As discussed here, the paper found no real evidence for any such thing.

The paper found the following:
  • Studying thousands of brain proteins, the study found that virtually all proteins in brains are very short-lived, with half-lives of less than a week.
  • Table 2 of the paper gives specific half-life estimates for the most long-lasting brain proteins, and in this table only 10 out of thousands of brain proteins had half-lives of 10 days or longer.
  • Of the proteins whose half-life is estimated in Table 2, only one of them has a half-life of longer than 30 days, that protein having a half-life of only 32 days.
  • A graph in the paper indicates that none of the synapse proteins had a half-life of more than 35 days.
So what was the title of this paper finding the undesired result of no evidence for synapse proteins with a lifetime of years? It was this: 'Identification of long-lived synaptic proteins by proteomic analysis of synaptosome protein turnover.” The paper thereby masked and stifled the actual observational result, that no truly long-lived synaptic proteins were found.

Way #6: Get Your Study's Press Release to Mask the Undesired Result with a Headline Not Mentioning It

How a scientific paper is reported is determined not just by the title used for the paper but the headline used in the press release announcing the paper. Such press releases often mask or hide undesired observational results. A good example is the press release for the scientific paper just discussed, which had the very misleading title, “In Mice, Long-Lasting Brain Proteins Offer Clues to How Memories Last a Lifetime.” This title masked and stifled the actual observational result, that no evidence of any synaptic proteins lasting years was found.

A scientist may claim that he has nothing to do with the headline used by the university press office when it issues a press release describing the scientist's study. But I suspect the typical situation is that such a press release is sent to the scientist before it is released, with the scientist having the opportunity to object if anything in the press release is inaccurate or misleading.

Way #7: Bury the Undesired Result Outside of the Abstract, Placing It Within a Sea of Details

If a scientist gets an undesired result, one way to kind of stifle it is to not state the result in the abstract of the paper, but to place it somewhere deep inside the paper, surrounded by paragraphs and paragraphs of fine details. Only the most diligent readers of the paper will notice the result. Since most scientific papers are hidden behind paywalls, with only the paper abstract being easily discovered through a web search, the result will be that very few people will ever read about the undesired result.

Way #8: State the Undesired Result Using Jargon That Almost No One Can Understand

Yet another way for a scientist to stifle an undesired result is to state the result using some fancy jargon or mathematical expression that almost no one will be able to understand. Such a thing is easy to do, just by using “science speak” that is like some foreign language to the average reader. For example, if the paper has found that some popular pill increases the chance of people dying, such a result can be announced by saying that the pill "produces a statistically significant prognostic detriment," a phrase a reader will be unlikely to understand. 

Way #9: Attack Someone's Methodology Producing an Undesired Result

The previous ways involved how a scientist may stifle or evade a result that came up in his own activity. But there are also ways to stifle or evade results produced by other people. Let's look at some of those.

One way is to attack the methodology of an study that produced a result you don't want to accept. For example, if an ESP experimenter got a result indicating ESP exists, you can complain about a lack of screens between the test subject and the observer. If such screens are used, you can complain that the observer and the experimenter were not in separate rooms. If they were in separate rooms, you can complain that a bit of noise might have traveled between the rooms. If the rooms were far-separated, you can complain that maybe the test subject could have peeked through a keyhole or a transom, or left a secret video camera somewhere.

Although there is nothing wrong per se in attacking the methodology of an experiment, given that many scientific studies have a very poor methodology, it should be noted that methodological criticisms often involve hypocrisy. Scientist X will often complain about a lack of some thing in Scientist Y's work, when Scientist X does not include that thing in his own experiments.

Way #10: Try to Undermine Confidence in Those Reporting the Unwanted Observations

An expert may use several different techniques to undermine confidence in an observer who has reported an unwanted observation. One commonly used technique is what is called gaslighting. It involves making one or more insinuations that the observer is suffering from some psychological problem, credibility problem or observational problem. 


shaming


Way #11: Speak As If the Observations Were Not Made

One of the most common techniques an expert may use to stifle an unwanted observational result is the technique of simply speaking as if some type of observational result was never made, without trying to discredit or even mention the undesired observations. For example, it is not uncommon for neuroscientists to say that there is no evidence that consciousness can continue after signs of brain activity have ceased, despite very strong evidence that exactly such a thing happens during many near-death experience.  To give another example, scientists often simply claim there is no evidence for paranormal phenomena, despite the very strong laboratory evidence for ESP that has been collected over many years. 


Way #12: "Speculate Away" the Undesired Observations


Faced with an undesired result, a scientist will often resort to elaborate speculations designed to explain away the result.  Here are some examples: 

(1) Faced with nothing but negative results from decades of searches for extraterrestrial radio signals,  scientists have resorted to speculations (such as the zoo hypothesis) designed to allow them to continue to believe that our galaxy is filled with intelligent life. 
(2) Faced with observational results suggesting that scientists don't well understand the composition of the universe or the dynamics of stellar movements, scientists invented the speculations of dark energy and dark matter,  rather than confess their ignorance about the composition of the universe  and the dynamics of stellar movements. 
(3) Faced with evidence that the proteins in synapses are too short-lived for synapses to be a storage place for memories, scientists created very elaborate chemical speculations designed to explain away this result.
(4) Faced with undesired evidence from near-death experiences that human consciousness can keep operating after brains have shut down, scientists created various elaborate speculations designed to explain away such evidence, including speculations of secret caches of hallucinogens in the brain that have not yet been discovered. 

Way #13: Stigmatize or "Quarantine" the Undesired Observation, by Claiming That "It Isn't Science"

The word "science" has multiple definitions. An "operational" definition of science is the effort to establish truth by the systematic study of observations and experiments. According to such a definition, any good methodology observation of something spooky qualifies as science. But there's a much more stringent definition of science, the definition of "facts established by observations and experiments." Using that more stringent definition, very many observations can be thrown away, on the basis that a fact was not established. Such an exclusion is improper, because the factuality of some Phenomenon X is established after a certain number of observations are made of that phenomenon; and if you always throw each new observation of that phenomenon, you are improperly preventing any possibility of establishing the factuality of the phenomenon. 

scientific censorship

Way #14: Claim Impossibility

Trying to sweep under the rug unwanted observations by claiming impossibility is one of the "oldest tricks in the book." It works like this: you just claim that whatever offending observation was reported cannot possibly have occurred, because such a thing is impossible. 

An example of this way being used was when Thomas Jefferson rejected a report of a meteorite fall, using what seemed to him the unassailable logic that stones cannot fall from the sky. He thought that Newton had revealed the clockwork orderliness of the cosmos, and that the idea of stones falling from the sky was therefore impossible. 

Almost always what is going in such impossibility claims is just someone reasoning along the lines of, "I believe for certain that X is true, but observation Y conflicts with my belief, so Y is impossible."  Instead of using such reasoning, what he should be doing is recognizing the offending observation as an anomaly, and a possible sign that the cherished contradicted belief may be wrong. 

Thomas Kuhn's philosophy of science had a good grasp of the importance of anomalies. Seemingly impossible anomalies may be the seeds of scientific revolutions, new outlooks on reality in which the once-regarded-as-impossible anomaly is recognized as both possible and observed. 

Kuhn philosophy of science

Way #15: Claim Irrationality

Another trick involves mounting the "high horse" of claimed rationality. It's a pretty easy trick to use. You just claim that any offending observations are examples of "irrationality" that must be discarded by "rational" people like yourself. Almost always the claim of irrationality is unfounded. 

For example, someone may discard all reports of apparitions, on the grounds that apparitions are irrational. But under the theory that humans have souls, an apparition sighting of a deceased person is not at all irrational. Similarly, an observation of little green men emerging from a flying saucer is not at all irrational, under the not-obviously-irrational idea that there is life on many other planets. 

Way #16: Just Avoid Mentioning the Undesired Observations, and Make No Mention of Them in Textbooks or Authoritative Subject Reviews

The final way is the simplest way for experts to stifle unwanted observations. They can simply avoid mentioning the observational results in places where they should be discussed, places like textbooks and review articles written by scientists.  This way is used so massively that certain science information sources (such as the journal Nature and typical textbooks) effectively act like "filter bubbles," preventing their readers from learning about many important facts that may conflict with their worldviews. 

scientific censorship